Skip to main content

Shop listings, maps, and events. Sponsored content is always labeled. How it works

Vintage · WI

Vintage card shops in Wisconsin

Card shops specialising in vintage cards — what counts as vintage, how condition drives price, and how to avoid altered cards.

Listed shops
5
Cities
5

Vintage shops in Wisconsin

  1. 3807 South Packard Avenue, St. Francis, WI 53235

    The Mana Vault carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, sports cards, vintage, and comics from South Packard Avenue in Saint Francis, Wisconsin. The listing adds that it runs in-store events. Opening hours are published for Tuesday to Sunday, with Monday shown as closed. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at themanavault.com. The same table shows that it stays open as late as 11pm and both weekend days are listed. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +2 more

  2. BMW Sportscards

    Hours unknown

    555 Donofrio Dr, Madison, WI 53719

    BMW Sportscards is a card shop in Madison, Wisconsin, on Donofrio Drive, listed for sports cards, baseball, vintage, and grading. A phone number and an official website at bmwcards.com are both on the listing. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections and opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Vintage · +1 more

  3. 324 E Main St, Waupun, WI 53963

    Real Sportscards - Wisconsin is a card shop on East Main Street in Waupun, Wisconsin. Sports coverage on the record runs to sports cards and baseball. Vintage and grading also appear on the record. Real Sportscards - Wisconsin also handles grading submissions. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at realsportscards.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Vintage · Grading · +1 more

  4. 1805 Barton Ave, West Bend, WI 53090

    Toy Box Toys & TCG is a card shop in West Bend, Wisconsin, on Barton Avenue, listed for Pokémon, sports cards, and vintage. On the services side, it buys collections. Hours are published for all seven days, with the latest close at 7pm. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at toyboxtoyswi.com. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Vintage

  5. 4800 Golf Rd, Eau Claire, WI 54701

    Coulee Cards & Gaming is a card shop on Golf Road in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. Coulee Cards & Gaming spans both halves of the hobby: Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh! in trading card games, and sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball in sports. Vintage and grading also appear on the record. Coulee Cards & Gaming also buys collections and runs in-store events. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at couleecards.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Pokémon · Sports cards · Grading · +6 more

What to look for

Storage that shows respect for the material

Sleeves, holders, upright storage, away from direct light. Vintage sitting loose in a tray tells you everything about how it has been handled and how it was bought.

Condition described before you ask

A shop that points out the crease, the soft corner, or the off-centre cut is a shop that expects to sell to you again.

The rest is on the vintage page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.