Isthmus City Card Show — November 2026
Sat, Nov 14 · 10:00 AM–2:00 PM
Madison East High School · Madison, WI
Madison, WI
Card shops in Madison, Wisconsin
CardShopMap lists 2 shops for collectors searching in Madison, Wisconsin: BMW Sportscards and Misty Mountain Games. Across these listings, category tags include baseball, grading, Magic: The Gathering, and Pokémon, and service tags include events / tournaments. Of these shops, one publishes opening hours, all 2 publish phone numbers, and all 2 publish official websites. By listing count, baseball on 1, grading on 1, and Magic: The Gathering on 1 carry each category tag. On the service side, events / tournaments on 1. For planning a visit, 1 publish Saturday hours. Before driving, confirm hours and availability with the shop — details can change.
- Verified shops
- 2
- Other listings
- 8
- Complete listings
- 2
- Upcoming events
- 2
- Data imported
- Aug 17, 2026
How many card shops are in Madison?
CardShopMap lists 2 card shops in Madison, Wisconsin, 2 of them with a full address, a way to get in touch, and at least one published category. 1 listing publishes opening hours; the rest are worth a call before you drive over.
The listings with the most detail are Misty Mountain Games at 4672 Cottage Grove Rd, which lists Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering, and BMW Sportscards at 555 Donofrio Dr, which lists Sports cards, Baseball, and Vintage.
The most commonly listed specialties across the market are tied at 1 shop each: Baseball, Grading, Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, Sports cards, and Vintage. 1 runs in-store events.
2 upcoming events are listed in Madison. These listings were compiled from public sources and last imported on . Send a correction if something here is out of date.
| Shop | Carries | Open right now | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Misty Mountain Games4672 Cottage Grove Rd | Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering | Closed | (608) 441-0312 |
| BMW Sportscards555 Donofrio Dr | Sports cards, Baseball, and Vintage | Hours unknown | (608) 833-5515 |
Filter by category
Showing 0 of 0 shops matching your filters (2 in total).
Every card shop listed in Madison, Wisconsin
No shops match those filters
All 2 Madison shops are still available on the unfiltered page.
Other listings in Madison, Wisconsin (8)
These listings have a complete address and contact method but have not yet been confirmed against the shop’s own website or an owner claim, so they are not counted above. How listings are verified.
Events in Madison
PokeKon Fest Madison - November 2026
Sat, Nov 21 · 10:00 AM–5:00 PM
DoubleTree by Hilton Madison East · Madison, WI
Keep looking
All shops in WisconsinStatewide directory and eventsSearch the national mapEvery published shop, with the same ordered list
Nearby published markets
Card shops in Madison: common questions
Which card shops in Madison publish opening hours?
1 Madison listing publishes opening hours: Misty Mountain Games. Hours come from public sources and can change, so check the individual listing before you drive over.
What can you do at a card shop in Madison?
Across the 2 listed Madison, Wisconsin shops, the services that appear most often are in-store events (1 shop). 2 upcoming events are also on the Madison calendar.
How were these Madison shops chosen?
Each listing’s name, address, and at least one contact method were confirmed from the shop’s official website, owner update, or another public source. Ordering is organic; sponsored slots are labeled separately. 2 listed shops, 2 of them complete enough to act on. Read the full gate.
Something look wrong?
These listings were imported from public sources on Aug 17, 2026 and are not individually re-checked. Send a correction or claim the listing if it’s your shop.