Effingham, IL

Card shops in Effingham, Illinois

CardShopMap lists 3 shops for collectors searching in Effingham, Illinois: Baseball Card Connection, Conspectus Gaming, and Mikes Cardex. Across these listings, category tags include baseball, Disney Lorcana, Magic: The Gathering, and One Piece, and service tags include events / tournaments, buys cards, and sells cards. Of these shops, all 3 publish opening hours, all 3 publish phone numbers, and all 3 publish official websites. By listing count, baseball on 1, Disney Lorcana on 1, and Magic: The Gathering on 1 carry each category tag. On the service side, events / tournaments on 2 and buys cards on 1. For planning a visit, all 3 publish Saturday hours and 1 is tagged as buying cards. Before driving, confirm hours and availability with the shop — details can change.

Verified shops: 3
Complete listings: 3
Upcoming events: 0
Data imported: Aug 17, 2026

How many card shops are in Effingham?

CardShopMap lists 3 card shops in Effingham, Illinois, 3 of them with a full address, a way to get in touch, and at least one published category. 3 listings publish opening hours; the rest are worth a call before you drive over.

The listings with the most detail are Baseball Card Connection at 313 West Jefferson Avenue, which lists Baseball and Sports cards, and Conspectus Gaming at 302 W Jefferson Ave, which lists Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and One Piece.

The most commonly listed specialties across the market are tied at 1 shop each: Baseball, Disney Lorcana, Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, Pokémon, Sports cards, and Vintage. 1 shop buys collections and 2 run in-store events.

No Effingham events are on the calendar right now. These listings were compiled from public sources and last imported on Aug 17, 2026. Send a correction if something here is out of date.

3 of the most complete Effingham listings, at a glance.
Shop	Carries	Open right now	Phone
Baseball Card Connection313 West Jefferson Avenue	Baseball and Sports cards	Closed	(217) 342-2539
Conspectus Gaming302 W Jefferson Ave	Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and One Piece	Open now	(570) 244-2582
Mikes Cardex1901 S 4th St	Not recorded	Closed	(217) 708-7089

Showing 1 of 1 shops matching your filters (3 in total).

Conspectus Gaming
Open now
302 W Jefferson Ave, Effingham, IL 62401
Conspectus Gaming carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, and vintage from West Jefferson Avenue in Effingham, Illinois. The listing adds that it runs in-store events. Opening hours are published for Wednesday to Saturday. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at cogclub.games. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +2 more

Written by us, not supplied by any shop.

How to find a card shop worth the drive
Most people pick a card shop by distance. Distance is the least useful thing about a shop. Here is what to check instead.
Card shop red flags: when to walk away
A high price is not automatically a red flag. Hidden rules, pressure, and claims you cannot verify are.
Your first visit to a card shop: what to expect
You do not need expert knowledge or a large budget. A short list and a few direct questions are enough.

Keep looking

All shops in IllinoisStatewide directory and events Search the national mapEvery published shop, with the same ordered list

Nearby published markets

Card shops in Effingham: common questions

Which Effingham card shops buy collections?

1 of the 3 Effingham shops listed on CardShopMap says it buys cards: Baseball Card Connection. Call ahead — what a shop buys and what it pays change week to week.

Which card shops in Effingham publish opening hours?

3 Effingham listings publish opening hours: Baseball Card Connection, Conspectus Gaming, and Mikes Cardex. Hours come from public sources and can change, so check the individual listing before you drive over.

What can you do at a card shop in Effingham?

Across the 3 listed Effingham, Illinois shops, the services that appear most often are in-store events (2 shops), buying collections (1 shop), and over-the-counter sales (1 shop).

How were these Effingham shops chosen?

Each listing’s name, address, and at least one contact method were confirmed from the shop’s official website, owner update, or another public source. Ordering is organic; sponsored slots are labeled separately. 3 listed shops, 3 of them complete enough to act on. Read the full gate.

Something look wrong?

These listings were imported from public sources on Aug 17, 2026 and are not individually re-checked. Send a correction or claim the listing if it’s your shop.

1 shop filtered

Clear Map