Effingham, IL

Card shops in Effingham, Illinois

Browse card shops in Effingham, Illinois, with available addresses, contact details, hours, categories, and directions.

Showing 3 of 3 shops.

Baseball Card Connection
Closed
313 West Jefferson Avenue, Effingham, IL 62401
Card shop in Effingham, Illinois.
Baseball · Sports cards
Conspectus Gaming
Closed
302 W Jefferson Ave, Effingham, IL 62401
Card shop in Effingham, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +2 more
Mikes Cardex
Closed
1901 S 4th St, Effingham, IL 62401
Card shop in Effingham, Illinois.

Events in Effingham

Aug21
Friday Night Magic at Conspectus Gaming
Fri, Aug 21 · 6:00 PM–10:00 PM
Conspectus Gaming · Effingham, IL
Aug22
Organised play at Mikes Cardex
Sat, Aug 22 · 12:00 PM–5:00 PM
Mikes Cardex · Effingham, IL

Written by us, not supplied by any shop.

How to find a card shop worth the drive
Most people pick a card shop by distance. Distance is the least useful thing about a shop. Here is what to check instead.
Card grading explained: PSA, BGS, CGC and SGC compared
Grading is a third party's opinion of condition, sealed in plastic. Which third party you pick changes what the card sells for — sometimes by a multiple.
How to sell your card collection to a shop without getting lowballed
A shop paying 40% of retail is not necessarily ripping you off. A shop that will not explain how it got to a number is. Here is the difference.

How were these shops chosen?: Each listing’s name, address, and at least one contact method were confirmed from the shop’s official website, owner update, or another public source. Ordering is organic; sponsored slots are labeled separately.
Why is Effingham published?: 3 listed shops, 3 of them complete enough to act on. Read the full gate.
Something look wrong?: Facts were last checked Aug 17, 2026. Send a correction or claim the listing if it’s your shop.

3 shops