Skip to main content
CardShopMap
Add a shop

Shop listings, maps, and events. Sponsored content is always labeled. How it works

Vintage · IN

Vintage card shops in Indiana

CardShopMap lists 10 vintage shops in Indiana. They are spread across 10 cities, including Batesville (1), Brownsburg (1), and Crown Point (1).

Listed shops
10
Cities
10
All shops in Indiana

Where can I buy vintage cards in Indiana?

CardShopMap lists 10 vintage shops in Indiana. They are spread across 10 cities, including Batesville (1), Brownsburg (1), and Crown Point (1). Of those listings, 2 publish opening hours, 3 are tagged as buying cards, and 2 handle grading submissions. Beyond vintage, they also carry sports cards (7), comics (5), and grading (5).

Every listing links an official website and 9 carry a phone number. 8 listings publish no opening hours at all, so call those before you drive over.

No city carries more than one listed vintage shop.

The listings carrying the most detail are Prideland Comics & Collectibles at 5668 Crawfordsville Road #D in Speedway, Hot Spot Collectibles And Toys Llc at 650 Dale Schrier Dr Ste F in Brownsburg, and Corn Coast Comics at 23 E Market St in Huntington.

Compare every card shop listed in Indiana

Indiana cities with listed vintage shops.
CityShopsPublish hours
Batesville11
Brownsburg10
Crown Point10
Dyer10
Fort Wayne10
Gary10
Huntington10
Indianapolis city (balance)10

Vintage shops in Indiana

  1. Prideland Comics & Collectibles

    Closed

    5668 Crawfordsville Road #D, Speedway, IN 46224

    Prideland Comics & Collectibles is a card shop trading from Crawfordsville Road in Speedway, Indiana. On the trading card game side it lists Pokémon; on the sports side, sports cards. Vintage, grading, and comics also appear on the record. It sells cards over the counter and handles grading submissions. The hours on file cover Wednesday to Sunday. Contact details on file are a phone number and cgccomics.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Comics · Grading · Pokémon · +2 more

  2. Hot Spot Collectibles And Toys Llc

    Hours unknown

    650 Dale Schrier Dr Ste F, Brownsburg, IN 46112

    Hot Spot Collectibles And Toys Llc is a card shop in Brownsburg, Indiana, on Dale Schrier Drive, listed for vintage, grading, and comics. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at hotspotcollectiblesandtoys.com. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections and opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Vintage · Comics · Grading

  3. Corn Coast Comics

    Hours unknown

    23 E Market St, Huntington, IN 46750

    Corn Coast Comics is a card shop trading from East Market Street in Huntington, Indiana. Trading card games on the listing are Pokémon, and the sports categories are sports cards and baseball. Vintage and comics also appear on the record. It runs an online store. Contact details on file are a phone number and thecorncoast.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Comics · Pokémon · Sports cards · +2 more

  4. Indiana Sportscard Guys

    Hours unknown

    406 W 4th St, Milford, IN 46542

    Indiana Sportscard Guys is a card shop in Milford, Indiana, on West 4th Street, listed for sports cards, vintage, and grading. On the services side, it buys collections. A phone number and an official website at indianasportscardguys.com are both on the listing. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Vintage · Grading

  5. Uptown Sports Cards

    Closed

    25 E George St, Batesville, IN 47006

    Uptown Sports Cards is a card shop on East George Street in Batesville, Indiana. Sports coverage on the record runs to sports cards and baseball. Vintage and grading also appear on the record. Uptown Sports Cards also runs an online store. It opens every day — 11:30am to 6:30pm on weekdays, midnight to midnight on Saturday and Sunday. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at uptownsportscards.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Vintage · +1 more

  6. Moonshot Games

    Hours unknown

    881 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis city (balance), IN 46204

    Moonshot Games is a card shop in Indianapolis, Indiana, on Massachusetts Avenue, listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Disney Lorcana, and vintage. On the services side, it runs in-store events and runs an online store, and flags itself as beginner-friendly. Contact details on file are a phone number and moonshotgamestore.com. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Disney Lorcana · +1 more

  7. Retro Trading Cards & Collectibles

    Hours unknown

    4121 Cleveland St, Gary, IN 46408

    Retro Trading Cards & Collectibles is a card shop in Gary, Indiana, on Cleveland Street, listed for Pokémon, One Piece, sports cards, vintage, grading, and comics. On the services side, it buys collections, handles grading submissions, and runs an online store. retrotradingcardscollectibles.com is on file as the official website; no phone number is recorded. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Comics · Pokémon · One Piece · +3 more

  8. More Fun Sports Cards

    Hours unknown

    706 Joliet St, Dyer, IN 46311

    More Fun Sports Cards carries sports cards, baseball, football, basketball, vintage, and comics from Joliet Street in Dyer, Indiana. A phone number and an official website at morefunsportscards.com are both on the listing. The record does not yet cover whether it buys collections and opening hours, so this page does not claim to. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +3 more

  9. Mega Replay

    Hours unknown

    5511 Coldwater Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46825

    Mega Replay is a card shop on Coldwater Road in Fort Wayne, Indiana. Categories recorded against Mega Replay are Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh!. Vintage also appears on the record. Mega Replay also buys collections. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at discreplay.com. What the record cannot tell you is opening hours. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · Vintage

  10. Forever Young Sports Cards

    Hours unknown

    166 S West St, Crown Point, IN 46307

    Forever Young Sports Cards is a card shop trading from South West Street in Crown Point, Indiana. The sports category on the listing is sports cards. Vintage also appears on the record. It runs an online store. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at foreveryoungsportscards.com. Still missing from the record: opening hours. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Vintage

What to look for

A view on alteration

Trimming and recolouring are real problems in vintage. Ask how they check. A shop with no answer has not thought about it.

Graded vintage where the stakes are high

For expensive vintage, a slab from a recognised company removes both the condition argument and much of the authenticity risk. Ask why anything expensive is still raw.

The rest is on the vintage page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.