Skip to main content
CardShopMap
Add a shop

Shop listings, maps, and events. Sponsored content is always labeled. How it works

Baseball · NY

Baseball card shops in New York

CardShopMap lists 15 baseball shops in New York. They are spread across 14 cities, including New York (2), Buffalo (1), and Deer Park (1).

Listed shops
15
Cities
14
All shops in New York

Where can I buy baseball cards in New York?

CardShopMap lists 15 baseball shops in New York. They are spread across 14 cities, including New York (2), Buffalo (1), and Deer Park (1). Of those listings, 8 publish opening hours and 1 is tagged as buying cards. Beyond baseball, they also carry football (12), sports cards (12), and basketball (10).

Every listing links an official website and all of them carry a phone number. 7 listings publish no opening hours at all, so call those before you drive over.

New York carries the most, with 2 listed shops.

The listings carrying the most detail are East Coast Card Collector at 410 State Route 376 in Hopewell Junction, Hot Flips at 87 Eads St in West Babylon, and ToyWiz at 347 W Route 59 in Nanuet.

Compare every card shop listed in New York

New York cities with listed baseball shops.
CityShopsPublish hours
New York21
Buffalo11
Deer Park10
Harris Hill11
Hopewell Junction11
Hudson Falls10
Larchmont10
Le Roy10

Baseball shops in New York

  1. East Coast Card Collector

    Closed

    410 State Route 376, Hopewell Junction, NY 12533

    East Coast Card Collector is a card shop trading from State Route 376 in East Fishkill, New York. East Coast Card Collector spans both halves of the hobby: Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, and Disney Lorcana in trading card games, and sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball in sports. The hours on file cover Tuesday to Sunday. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at eastcoastcardcollector.com. On the same record, both weekend days are listed. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +5 more

  2. Hot Flips

    By appointment

    87 Eads St, West Babylon, NY 11704

    Hot Flips is a card shop in West Babylon, New York, on Eads Street, listed for Pokémon, sports cards, baseball, football, grading, and comics. On the services side, it runs an online store. The record lists it as open by appointment rather than on fixed hours. A phone number and an official website at hotflips.com are both on the listing. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Comics · Pokémon · Sports cards · +3 more

  3. ToyWiz

    Hours unknown

    347 W Route 59, Nanuet, NY 10954

    ToyWiz carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, sports cards, baseball, and comics from West Route 59 in Nanuet, New York. The listing adds that it runs an online store. Contact details on file are a phone number and toywiz.com. The record does not yet cover opening hours, so this page does not claim to. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more

  4. Slope Comic & Collectibles

    Open now

    151 7th Ave, New York, NY 11215

    Slope Comic & Collectibles is a card shop in New York, New York, on 7th Avenue, listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, baseball, basketball, and comics. Hours are published for all seven days, with the latest close at 6pm. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at slopecomics.com. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +2 more

  5. Perfectly Centered

    Hours unknown

    1989 Palmer Ave, Larchmont, NY 10538

    Perfectly Centered is a card shop in Larchmont, New York, on Palmer Avenue, listed for sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at perfectlycenteredstore.com. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections and opening hours, and the listing does not guess. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +1 more

  6. Dave & Adam's Card World

    Closed

    5575 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY 14221

    Dave & Adam's Card World carries One Piece, sports cards, baseball, and football from Transit Road in Williamsville, New York. Hours are published for all seven days, with the latest close at 8pm. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at daveandadamsstore.com. The record does not yet cover whether it buys collections, so this page does not claim to. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Sports cards · One Piece · Baseball · +1 more

  7. Planet Hobbywood

    Hours unknown

    8611 Jamaica Ave, New York, NY 11421

    Planet Hobbywood is a card shop on Jamaica Avenue in Woodhaven, New York. On the trading card game side it lists Pokémon; on the sports side, baseball, football, and basketball. Planet Hobbywood also runs an online store. Contact details on file are a phone number and planethobbywood.com. What the record cannot tell you is opening hours. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Pokémon · Baseball · Football · +1 more

  8. Triple Crown Sports Cards

    Closed

    23 E Main St, Westfield, NY 14787

    Triple Crown Sports Cards is a card shop in Westfield, New York, on East Main Street, listed for sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball. Opening hours are published for Tuesday to Saturday, and it is shown closed on Sunday and Monday. Contact details on file are a phone number and triplecrownsportscards.com. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections, and the listing does not guess. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +1 more

  9. Dio’s Treasures

    Hours unknown

    8 Lake St, Le Roy, NY 14482

    Dio’s Treasures is a card shop trading from Lake Street in Le Roy, New York. Trading card games on the listing are Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh!, and the sports categories are sports cards, baseball, and basketball. Vintage, grading, and comics also appear on the record. It runs an online store. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at ebay.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · Sports cards · +5 more

  10. Get Good Gaming Company

    Hours unknown

    71 S Main St, New City, NY 10956

    Get Good Gaming Company is a card shop trading from South Main Street in Clarkstown, New York. Get Good Gaming Company spans both halves of the hobby: Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, and Disney Lorcana in trading card games, and sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball in sports. Vintage and grading also appear on the record. It runs in-store events. A phone number and an official website at getgoodgamingcompany.com are both on the listing. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +8 more

  11. Smoke and Mirrors Hobby

    Hours unknown

    3 Brandywine Dr, Deer Park, NY 11729

    Smoke and Mirrors Hobby is a card shop on Brandywine Drive in Deer Park, New York. On the trading card game side it lists Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, and Disney Lorcana; on the sports side, baseball, football, and basketball. Smoke and Mirrors Hobby also buys collections. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at smokeandmirrorshobby.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +4 more

  12. Dave and Adam's Card World

    Closed

    4254 Ridge Lea Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226

    Dave and Adam's Card World is a card shop trading from Ridge Lea Road in Buffalo, New York. On the trading card game side it lists One Piece; on the sports side, sports cards, baseball, and football. The record carries opening hours for every day of the week, closing as late as 8pm. Contact details on file are a phone number and dacwstore.com. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.

    Sports cards · One Piece · Baseball · +1 more

  13. Great Lakes Sports Cards

    Closed

    4161 Transit Rd, Harris Hill, NY

    Great Lakes Sports Cards carries Pokémon, sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball from Transit Road in Buffalo, New York. The listing adds that it runs an online store. Hours are published for all seven days, with the latest close at 6pm. Contact details on file are a phone number and greatlakessportscards.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Baseball · +2 more

  14. Dave & Adam's Card World

    Closed

    2217 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14223

    Dave & Adam's Card World is a card shop trading from Sheridan Drive in Tonawanda, New York. On the trading card game side it lists One Piece; on the sports side, sports cards, baseball, and football. The record carries opening hours for every day of the week, closing as late as 8pm. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at daveandadamsstore.com. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Sports cards · One Piece · Baseball · +1 more

  15. JB's Trading Card Co

    Hours unknown

    1104 Dix Ave, Hudson Falls, NY 12839

    JB's Trading Card Co carries sports cards, baseball, football, basketball, and vintage from Dix Avenue in Hudson Falls, New York. A phone number and an official website at marketplace.beckett.com are both on the listing. The record does not yet cover whether it buys collections and opening hours, so this page does not claim to. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +2 more

What to look for

Vintage stored and handled properly

Pre-1980 cards in sleeves or holders, not loose in a shoebox. Vintage condition is fragile and a shop that stores it carelessly is telling you what it knows.

Honest condition language on raw vintage

A shop should point out the soft corner or the off-centre cut before you find it. On vintage, condition is most of the price.

The rest is on the baseball page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.