Magic: The Gathering · IN

Magic: The Gathering card shops in Indiana

CardShopMap lists 15 Magic: The Gathering shops in Indiana. They are spread across 13 cities, including Bloomington (2), Fishers (2), and Brownsburg (1).

Listed shops: 15
Cities: 13

All shops in Indiana

Where can I buy magic: the gathering cards in Indiana?

CardShopMap lists 15 Magic: The Gathering shops in Indiana. They are spread across 13 cities, including Bloomington (2), Fishers (2), and Brownsburg (1). Of those listings, 5 publish opening hours and 2 are tagged as buying cards. Beyond Magic: The Gathering, they also carry Pokémon (11), Yu-Gi-Oh! (6), and comics (5).

Every listing links an official website and 14 carry a phone number. 10 listings publish no opening hours at all, so call those before you drive over.

No single city leads: Bloomington and Fishers each carry 2 listed shops.

The listings carrying the most detail are The Shop Collectibles at 10971 Four Seasons Place #106 in Crown Point, Friendly City Games at 118 N Lebanon St in Lebanon, and Atomic Planet Comics at 8906 E 96th St in Fishers.

Compare every card shop listed in Indiana

Indiana cities with listed magic: the gathering shops.
City	Shops	Publish hours
Bloomington	2	0
Fishers	2	1
Brownsburg	1	0
Crown Point	1	0
Elkhart	1	0
Evansville	1	0
Huntington	1	1
Indianapolis city (balance)	1	0

The Shop Collectibles
Hours unknown
10971 Four Seasons Place #106, Crown Point, IN 46307
The Shop Collectibles is a card shop trading from Four Seasons Place in Crown Point, Indiana. On the trading card game side it lists Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, and Disney Lorcana; on the sports side, sports cards. Grading and comics also appear on the record. It sells cards over the counter and runs in-store events. The listing links the shop's own site at theshopcollectibles.com, but no phone number is recorded. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Sports cards · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +5 more
Friendly City Games
Closed
118 N Lebanon St, Lebanon, IN 46052
Friendly City Games is a card shop trading from North Lebanon Street in Lebanon, Indiana. It is listed for Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering. It runs in-store events and runs an online store. The hours on file cover Wednesday, Thursday, Saturday, and Sunday, with Tuesday shown as closed. Contact details on file are a phone number and friendlycitygames.com. Also on the hours record: it stays open as late as 10pm and both weekend days are listed. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.
Magic: The Gathering · Pokémon
Atomic Planet Comics
Closed
8906 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037
Atomic Planet Comics is a card shop in Fishers, Indiana, on East 96th Street, listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, grading, and comics. Opening hours are published for Monday to Saturday, with Sunday shown as closed. A phone number and an official website at atomicplanet.net are both on the listing. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more
The Common Room
Hours unknown
223 S Pete Ellis Dr, Bloomington, IN 47408
The Common Room is a card shop in Bloomington, Indiana, on South Pete Ellis Drive, listed for Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and comics. On the services side, it runs in-store events. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at commonroomgames.com. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Card trading here was confirmed from the shop's own site rather than assumed from its name, though the address itself comes from imported place data.
Comics · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh!
Escape TCG & More LLC
Hours unknown
305 N Main St, Liberty, IN 47353
Escape TCG & More LLC carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Disney Lorcana, and sports cards from North Main Street in Liberty, Indiana. A phone number and an official website at escapetcg.com are both on the listing. The record does not yet cover whether it buys collections and opening hours, so this page does not claim to. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.
Sports cards · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more
2nd Play'R
Closed
5892 US Highway 6, Portage, IN 46368
2nd Play'R is a card shop in Portage, Indiana, on US Highway 6, listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and One Piece. On the services side, it buys collections and runs in-store events. Hours are published for all seven days, with the latest close at 7pm. Contact details on file are a phone number and 2ndplayr.com. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece
Coconuts
Hours unknown
711 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
Coconuts is a card shop in Evansville, Indiana, on North Green River Road, listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, and comics. Contact details on file are a phone number and fye.com. Nothing on file covers whether it buys collections and opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more
Moonshot Games
Hours unknown
881 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis city (balance), IN 46204
Moonshot Games is a card shop in Indianapolis, Indiana, on Massachusetts Avenue, listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Disney Lorcana, and vintage. On the services side, it runs in-store events and runs an online store, and flags itself as beginner-friendly. Contact details on file are a phone number and moonshotgamestore.com. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Disney Lorcana · +1 more
Gray Gauntlet Games
Hours unknown
7998 Centerpoint Dr, Fishers, IN 46256
Gray Gauntlet Games is a card shop on Centerpoint Drive in Fishers, Indiana. The trading card games on the listing are Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and Yu-Gi-Oh!. Gray Gauntlet Games also runs an online store. Contact details on file are a phone number and graygauntletgames.com. What the record cannot tell you is opening hours. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh!
LITKO Game Accessories
Hours unknown
2006 Warbler Dr, Valparaiso, IN 46383
LITKO Game Accessories is a card shop in Valparaiso, Indiana, on Warbler Drive, listed for Magic: The Gathering. On the services side, it runs in-store events and runs an online store. The listing carries a phone number and links the shop's own site at litko.net. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.
Magic: The Gathering
Common Room Games
Hours unknown
2642 W. 10th St., Bloomington, IN 47408
Common Room Games is a card shop in Bloomington, Indiana, on West 10th Street, listed for Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh!. On the services side, it runs in-store events. A phone number and an official website at commonroomgames.com are both on the listing. Nothing on file covers opening hours, and the listing does not guess. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh!
Abrams Cards and Collectibles
Closed
1512 S Heaton St, Knox, IN 46534
Abrams Cards and Collectibles is a card shop trading from South Heaton Street in Knox, Indiana. On the trading card game side it lists Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering; on the sports side, sports cards, baseball, football, and basketball. It buys collections. It is listed as open Tuesday to Saturday, 11am to 6pm, with Monday shown as closed. Contact details on file are a phone number and abramscards.com. On the same record, Saturday is listed but Sunday is not. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.
Sports cards · Pokémon · Baseball · +3 more
Bulldog Community Gaming
Hours unknown
1060 E Main St, Brownsburg, IN 46112
Bulldog Community Gaming is a card shop trading from East Main Street in Brownsburg, Indiana. The trading card games on the listing are Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and One Piece. It runs in-store events. A phone number and an official website at bulldogcommunitygaming.com are both on the listing. Still missing from the record: opening hours. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +1 more
TCB Games Inc
Closed
44 E Park Dr, Huntington, IN 46750
TCB Games Inc is a card shop trading from East Park Drive in Huntington, Indiana. It is listed for Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and Disney Lorcana. Comics also appears on the record. It runs an online store. The record carries opening hours for every day of the week, closing as late as 9pm. Contact details on file are a phone number and tcb.games. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more
Secret Door Games
Hours unknown
215 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46516
Secret Door Games is a card shop trading from South Main Street in Elkhart, Indiana. The single category on the listing is Magic: The Gathering. It runs an online store. Contact details on file are a phone number and secretdoorgames.org. Still missing from the record: opening hours. Confirmation that this is a card business came from the shop's own website; everything else is imported place data.
Magic: The Gathering

What to look for

Format literacy

Whether they know the local Commander scene, whether Standard fires, whether there is a Modern night. A shop that cannot tell you what its own players play is not running a community.

Play space that is usable

Enough tables, decent lighting, and somewhere to put a drink. Small things; they decide whether people stay.

The rest is on the magic: the gathering page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.