Grading companies can reject cards or return them without a standard numerical grade. Common reasons include suspected counterfeits, trimming or other alterations, severe damage, incomplete submissions, or service rules the card does not meet. If you submit through a PSA grading shop, ask how the shop handles rejections, fee refunds, and documentation before the card leaves the counter. Rejection is disappointing, but it is still useful information about authenticity or condition risk.
Reduce rejection odds by inspecting the card carefully, avoiding aggressive cleaning, photographing both sides, and disclosing known issues on intake paperwork. The grading mistakes guide and altered cards guide cover warning signs shops and collectors should catch early. If a card comes back rejected, keep the paperwork and do not quietly sell the card as if nothing happened. A transparent local shop can help you decide whether authentication, conservation, or a different service path makes sense next time.