Skip to main content
CardShopMap
Add a shop

Shop listings, maps, and events. Sponsored content is always labeled. How it works

Magic: The Gathering · IN

Magic: The Gathering card shops in Indiana

Magic: The Gathering shops with singles, sealed, and event play — what to look for in a shop's singles pricing, buylist, and Friday Night Magic.

Listed shops
15
Cities
13
All shops in Indiana

Magic: The Gathering shops in Indiana

  1. The Shop Collectibles

    Hours unknown

    10971 Four Seasons Place #106, Crown Point, IN 46307

    Card shop in Crown Point, Indiana.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +5 more

  2. Friendly City Games

    Closed

    118 N Lebanon St, Lebanon, IN 46052

    Card shop in Lebanon, Indiana.

    Magic: The Gathering · Pokémon

  3. Atomic Planet Comics

    Closed

    8906 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037

    Card shop in Fishers, Indiana.

    Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more

  4. The Common Room

    Hours unknown

    223 S Pete Ellis Dr, Bloomington, IN 47408

    Card shop in Bloomington, Indiana.

    Comics · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh!

  5. Escape TCG & More LLC

    Hours unknown

    305 N Main St, Liberty, IN 47353

    Card shop in Liberty, Indiana.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more

  6. 2nd Play'R

    Closed

    5892 US Highway 6, Portage, IN 46368

    Card shop in Portage, Indiana.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece

  7. Coconuts

    Hours unknown

    711 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715

    Card shop in Evansville, Indiana.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more

  8. Moonshot Games

    Hours unknown

    881 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis city (balance), IN 46204

    Card shop in Indianapolis, Indiana.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Disney Lorcana · +1 more

  9. Gray Gauntlet Games

    Hours unknown

    7998 Centerpoint Dr, Fishers, IN 46256

    Card shop in Fishers, Indiana.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh!

  10. LITKO Game Accessories

    Hours unknown

    2006 Warbler Dr, Valparaiso, IN 46383

    Card shop in Valparaiso, Indiana.

    Magic: The Gathering

  11. Common Room Games

    Hours unknown

    2642 W. 10th St., Bloomington, IN 47408

    Card shop in Bloomington, Indiana.

    Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh!

  13. Bulldog Community Gaming

    Hours unknown

    1060 E Main St, Brownsburg, IN 46112

    Card shop in Brownsburg, Indiana.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +1 more

  14. TCB Games Inc

    Closed

    44 E Park Dr, Huntington, IN 46750

    Card shop in Huntington, Indiana.

    Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more

  15. Secret Door Games

    Hours unknown

    215 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46516

    Card shop in Elkhart, Indiana.

    Magic: The Gathering

What to look for

Singles priced individually and kept current

Magic prices move constantly. A shop with a real singles operation reprices; one with a dusty binder at year-old numbers does not.

A buylist, or a willingness to quote one

Being able to sell cards back is half of what a local Magic shop is for. Ask what they pay on staples in the format you play.

The rest is on the magic: the gathering page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.