Prism Games
Closed2874 North Milwaukee Avenue, Chicago, IL 60618
Card shop in Chicago, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering · One Piece
Magic: The Gathering · IL
Magic: The Gathering card shops in Illinois
Magic: The Gathering shops with singles, sealed, and event play — what to look for in a shop's singles pricing, buylist, and Friday Night Magic.
- Listed shops
- 31
- Cities
- 28
Magic: The Gathering shops in Illinois
Titan Games
Closed723 South Neil Street, Champaign, IL 61820
Card shop in Champaign, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Disney Lorcana
GriffoNest Games
Hours unknown124 Cass Street Suite 2, Woodstock, IL 60098
Card shop in Woodstock, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering · Disney Lorcana
5550 North Broadway, Chicago, IL 60640
Card shop in Chicago, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering
Comic Buying Center
Closed624 E Park Ave, Libertyville, IL 60048
Card shop in Libertyville, Illinois.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +6 more
The Baseball Card King
Hours unknown1002 Geneva St, Shorewood, IL 60404
Card shop in Shorewood, Illinois.
Baseball · Sports cards · Pokémon · +5 more
Geek Inc Comics
Hours unknown994 W Army Trail Rd, Carol Stream, IL 60188
Card shop in Carol Stream, Illinois.
Comics · Magic: The Gathering
Otherside Games
Closed229 N Main St, Edwardsville, IL 62025
Card shop in Edwardsville, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Comics
Wild Growth Games
Closed820 Main St, Highland, IL 62249
Card shop in Highland, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +1 more
Game Night
Hours unknown104 Roosevelt St, Bartonville, IL 61607
Card shop in Bartonville, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering · Comics
Affinity for Gaming
Open now811 W Lincoln Hwy, DeKalb, IL 60115
Card shop in Dekalb, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering
Fantasy Books and Games
Closed1977 W US-50, O'Fallon, IL 62208
Card shop in O'Fallon, Illinois.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +2 more
Red Raccoon Games
Hours unknown301 N Main St, Bloomington, IL 61701
Card shop in Bloomington, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering
The Midtown Group
Hours unknown30 N La Salle St Ste 2250, Chicago, IL 60602
Card shop in Chicago, Illinois.
Comics · Magic: The Gathering · Sports cards · +1 more
Paper Escape
Hours unknown205 W 1st St, Dixon, IL 61021
Card shop in Dixon, Illinois.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering
1895 N Neltnor Blvd, West Chicago, IL 60185
Card shop in West Chicago, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering
Fair Game
Hours unknown19 S La Grange Rd, La Grange, IL 60525
Card shop in La Grange, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece
Wayward Geek
Hours unknown117 W Mondamin St, Minooka, IL 60447
Card shop in Minooka, Illinois.
Comics · Magic: The Gathering · Grading
2180 Oakland Dr, Sycamore, IL 60178
Card shop in Sycamore, Illinois.
Sports cards · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +2 more
The Bandits Hideout
Hours unknown357 Marketplace Dr, Freeburg, IL 62243
Card shop in Freeburg, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +1 more
Conspectus Gaming
Closed302 W Jefferson Ave, Effingham, IL 62401
Card shop in Effingham, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +2 more
The Pieceful Project
Hours unknown27 Jandus Rd, Cary, IL 60013
Card shop in Cary, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering
Cosmic Collectibles and Games
Hours unknown1402 Broadway Ave, Mattoon, IL 61938
Card shop in Mattoon, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more
The Baseball Card King
Hours unknown16200 S Lincoln Hwy Ste 100, Plainfield, IL 60586
Card shop in Plainfield, Illinois.
Baseball · Sports cards · Pokémon · +5 more
Fair Game
Hours unknown1015 Curtiss St, Downers Grove, IL 60515
Card shop in Downers Grove, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece
Geek Inc Comics
Hours unknown994 W Army Trail Rd, Carol Stream, IL 60188
Card shop in Carol Stream, Illinois.
Comics · Magic: The Gathering
Realms of Gaming
Closed300 Edwardsville Rd, Troy, IL 62294
Card shop in Troy, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering · Pokémon · One Piece · +1 more
Fantasy Book Inc
Closed1113 E Main St, Belleville, IL 62220
Card shop in Belleville, Illinois.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +2 more
Fye
Hours unknown77 River Oaks Center Dr, Calumet City, IL 60409
Card shop in Calumet City, Illinois.
Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more
Top Cut Collectibles
Closed7122 Ogden Ave, Berwyn, IL 60402
Card shop in Berwyn, Illinois.
Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +1 more
Affinity For Gaming
Open now19 Berkshire Dr, Crystal Lake, IL 60014
Card shop in Crystal Lake, Illinois.
Magic: The Gathering
What to look for
Singles priced individually and kept current
Magic prices move constantly. A shop with a real singles operation reprices; one with a dusty binder at year-old numbers does not.
A buylist, or a willingness to quote one
Being able to sell cards back is half of what a local Magic shop is for. Ask what they pay on staples in the format you play.
The rest is on the magic: the gathering page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.