Skip to main content
CardShopMap
Add a shop

Shop listings, maps, and events. Sponsored content is always labeled. How it works

Baseball · NY

Baseball card shops in New York

Card shops with baseball card inventory, from vintage commons and star cards to modern rookies, plus what to check before buying.

Listed shops
15
Cities
14
All shops in New York

Baseball shops in New York

  1. East Coast Card Collector

    Closed

    410 State Route 376, Hopewell Junction, NY 12533

    Card shop in East Fishkill, New York.

    Sports cards · Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +5 more

  2. Hot Flips

    By appointment

    87 Eads St, West Babylon, NY 11704

    Card shop in West Babylon, New York.

    Comics · Pokémon · Sports cards · +3 more

  3. ToyWiz

    Hours unknown

    347 W Route 59, Nanuet, NY 10954

    Card shop in Nanuet, New York.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more

  4. Slope Comic & Collectibles

    Closed

    151 7th Ave, New York, NY 11215

    Card shop in New York, New York.

    Comics · Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · +2 more

  5. Perfectly Centered

    Hours unknown

    1989 Palmer Ave, Larchmont, NY 10538

    Card shop in Larchmont, New York.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +1 more

  6. Hot Topic

    Closed

    358 Broadway Mall, Hicksville, NY 11801

    Card shop in Hicksville, New York.

    Comics · Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +3 more

  7. Dave & Adam's Card World

    Closed

    5575 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY 14221

    Card shop in Williamsville, New York.

    Sports cards · One Piece · Baseball · +1 more

  8. Planet Hobbywood

    Hours unknown

    8611 Jamaica Ave, New York, NY 11421

    Card shop in Woodhaven, New York.

    Pokémon · Baseball · Football · +1 more

  9. Triple Crown Sports Cards

    Closed

    23 E Main St, Westfield, NY 14787

    Card shop in Westfield, New York.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +1 more

  10. Dio’s Treasures

    Hours unknown

    8 Lake St, Le Roy, NY 14482

    Card shop in Le Roy, New York.

    Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · Sports cards · +5 more

  11. Get Good Gaming Company

    Hours unknown

    71 S Main St, New City, NY 10956

    Card shop in Clarkstown, New York.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · Yu-Gi-Oh! · +8 more

  12. Smoke and Mirrors Hobby

    Hours unknown

    3 Brandywine Dr, Deer Park, NY 11729

    Card shop in Deer Park, New York.

    Pokémon · Magic: The Gathering · One Piece · +4 more

  13. Dave and Adam's Card World

    Closed

    4254 Ridge Lea Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226

    Card shop in Buffalo, New York.

    Sports cards · One Piece · Baseball · +1 more

  14. Dave & Adam's Card World

    Closed

    2217 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14223

    Card shop in Tonawanda, New York.

    Sports cards · One Piece · Baseball · +1 more

  15. JB's Trading Card Co

    Hours unknown

    1104 Dix Ave, Hudson Falls, NY 12839

    Card shop in Hudson Falls, New York.

    Sports cards · Baseball · Football · +2 more

What to look for

Vintage stored and handled properly

Pre-1980 cards in sleeves or holders, not loose in a shoebox. Vintage condition is fragile and a shop that stores it carelessly is telling you what it knows.

Honest condition language on raw vintage

A shop should point out the soft corner or the off-centre cut before you find it. On vintage, condition is most of the price.

The rest is on the baseball page, along with the questions worth asking before you hand over a collection.