Skip to main content
CardShopMap
Add a shop

Shop listings, maps, and events. Sponsored content is always labeled. How it works

Islip, NY

Card shops in Islip, New York

CardShopMap lists 6 shops for collectors searching in Islip, New York: Milo Toys & Collectables and Next Generation Comics and Cards, plus 4 more listings. Across these listings, category tags include comics, Pokémon, sports cards, and Disney Lorcana, and service tags include events / tournaments and online store. Of these shops, 2 publish opening hours, all 6 publish phone numbers, and 4 publish official websites. These fields help compare which entries offer a direct way to confirm a visit, but they do not establish live stock or service availability. Before driving, open each shop profile and use its official website or phone number when published to confirm the address, today's hours, and whether the relevant category or service is current. For entries without direct contact information, look for a current official shop channel before setting out. Hours and contact details can change, and category or service tags may not describe every visit, so same-day confirmation is the safest plan.

Listed shops
2
Complete listings
2
Upcoming events
0
Data imported
Aug 17, 2026

How many card shops are in Islip?

CardShopMap lists 2 card shops in Islip, New York, 2 of them with a full address, a way to get in touch, and at least one published category. 2 listings publish opening hours; the rest are worth a call before you drive over.

The listings with the most detail are Milo Toys & Collectables at 941 Montauk Hwy, which lists Sports cards, Vintage, and Comics, and Retro Island Gaming at 87 Carleton Ave, which lists Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and One Piece.

The most commonly listed specialty across the market is Comics (2 of 2 shops), followed by Pokémon (2), Disney Lorcana (1), and One Piece (1). 1 runs in-store events.

No Islip events are on the calendar right now. These listings were compiled from public sources and last imported on . Send a correction if something here is out of date.

2 of the most complete Islip listings, at a glance.
ShopCarriesOpen right nowPhone
Milo Toys & Collectables941 Montauk HwySports cards, Vintage, and ComicsClosed(631) 641-7683
Retro Island Gaming87 Carleton AvePokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and One PieceOpen now(631) 650-1504

Filter by category

Showing 1 of 1 shops matching your filters (2 in total).

Every card shop listed in Islip, New York

  1. Retro Island Gaming

    Open now

    87 Carleton Ave, Islip, NY 11752

    Retro Island Gaming is a card shop in Islip, New York, on Carleton Avenue, listed for Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, and comics. On the services side, it runs in-store events and runs an online store. Published hours are 11am to 9pm, Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, with Tuesday shown as closed. A phone number and an official website at retroislandny.com are both on the listing. On the same record, both weekend days are listed. The shop's own website is what confirmed it trades cards; the address and contact details come from imported place data.

    Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · One Piece · +2 more

Keep looking

All shops in New YorkStatewide directory and eventsSearch the national mapEvery published shop, with the same ordered list

Nearby published markets

Card shops in Islip: common questions

Which card shops in Islip publish opening hours?
2 Islip listings publish opening hours: Milo Toys & Collectables and Retro Island Gaming. Hours come from public sources and can change, so check the individual listing before you drive over.
What can you do at a card shop in Islip?
Across the 2 listed Islip, New York shops, the services that appear most often are events / tournaments (1 shop) and online store (1 shop).
How were these Islip shops chosen?
Each listing’s name, address, and at least one contact method were confirmed from the shop’s official website, owner update, or another public source. Ordering is organic; sponsored slots are labeled separately. 2 listed shops, 2 of them complete enough to act on. Read the full gate.
Something look wrong?
These listings were imported from public sources on Aug 17, 2026 and are not individually re-checked. Send a correction or claim the listing if it’s your shop.

1 shop filtered

ClearMap