Islip, NY
Card shops in Islip, New York
CardShopMap lists 2 shops for collectors searching in Islip, New York: Milo Toys & Collectables and Retro Island Gaming. Across these listings, category tags include comics, Pokémon, Disney Lorcana, and One Piece, and service tags include events / tournaments and online store. Of these shops, all 2 publish opening hours, all 2 publish phone numbers, and all 2 publish official websites. By listing count, comics on 2, Pokémon on 2, and Disney Lorcana on 1 carry each category tag. On the service side, events / tournaments on 1 and online store on 1. For planning a visit, all 2 publish Saturday hours. Before driving, confirm hours and availability with the shop — details can change.
- Verified shops
- 2
- Other listings
- 3
- Complete listings
- 2
- Upcoming events
- 0
- Data imported
- Aug 17, 2026
How many card shops are in Islip?
CardShopMap lists 2 card shops in Islip, New York, 2 of them with a full address, a way to get in touch, and at least one published category. 2 listings publish opening hours; the rest are worth a call before you drive over.
The listings with the most detail are Milo Toys & Collectables at 941 Montauk Hwy, which lists Sports cards, Vintage, and Comics, and Retro Island Gaming at 87 Carleton Ave, which lists Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and One Piece.
The most commonly listed specialties across the market are tied at 2 shops each: Comics and Pokémon, followed by Disney Lorcana (1), One Piece (1), and Sports cards (1). 1 runs in-store events.
No Islip events are on the calendar right now. These listings were compiled from public sources and last imported on . Send a correction if something here is out of date.
| Shop | Carries | Open right now | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Milo Toys & Collectables941 Montauk Hwy | Sports cards, Vintage, and Comics | Closed | (631) 641-7683 |
| Retro Island Gaming87 Carleton Ave | Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and One Piece | Closed | (631) 650-1504 |
Filter by category
Showing 0 of 0 shops matching your filters (2 in total).
Every card shop listed in Islip, New York
No shops match those filters
All 2 Islip shops are still available on the unfiltered page.
Other listings in Islip, New York (3)
These listings have a complete address and contact method but have not yet been confirmed against the shop’s own website or an owner claim, so they are not counted above. How listings are verified.